The David S Operaworld blog

A series of commentary on the world of opera and of serious music hopefully with links to items of broader cultural interest, correlation with the subject at hand. There is plenty of room here for a certain amount of clowning around and general irreverence - not exclusive to me - but of course no trollers or spam please. Blog for coverage of the BBC PROMS 2010 - with thoroughly proofread/upgraded coverage of the 2009 Proms and of much else.

Thursday, May 3, 2012

HGO: Donizetti's Maria Stuarda (new) - first for company. Joyce di Donato. Katie Van Kooten. Patrick Summers. Kevin Newbury. 27.4.12.

Houston Grand Opera, in its fifty-seven year history has not until this time put on a production of the second opera in the Donizetti Tudor Queen trilogy, Maria Stuarda. Dame Joan Sutherland, during the sunset years of her career, had HGO provide her a staged revival of Anna Bolena. This event, HGO’s first Anna Bolena, automatically carried with it a sense of grandeur, just in anticipating Sutherland taking on this peak role for the first time, both in concert at Lincoln Center and on stage here. The Metropolitan Opera is amidst a Donizetti Tudor trilogy of its own that Peter Gelb had originally planned to have star Anna Netrebko throughout; Netrebko eventually reckoned it more prudent to commit only to Anna Bolena (seen on cinema screens last fall) thus far. Enduring operaphiles can still recall Beverly Sills taking on all three roles for major New York City Opera revival forty years ago.

Our new Maria Stuarda, originally to have been staged by Patrice Caurier and Moshe Leiser, proved only halfway convincing as new role for Houston favorite Joyce di Donato – anticipatory of her repeating the role for this opera’s first showing at the Met next season. Not terribly great theatrical excitement could necessarily have been expected from Caurier and Leiser, but at least probably a better sense of scale, and more elegant set design than we have had from who has come in instead.

Kevin Newbury’s production, with ponderous sets by Neil Patel, and mostly stylish costuming by Jessica Jahn, all making their HGO debuts, proved very ordinary.
While sticking to traditional blocking, and mostly reasonable interaction between cast members, Newbury remained on safe ground. His production also proved short on taking any risks. Statuesque childhood profiling of two queens involved at stage rear during Act One orchestral introduction proved inconclusive. Perhaps the audience needed visual stimulation until time for real action to begin. Such proved additionally insipid for pantomime of Elisabeth during an abridged and choppily performed Inno della morte – often instead haunting choral number three-fourths through Act Three.

Slow descending blocks of set design proved cumbersome - all eventually emulating some perverse obsessing over large objects. Regal emblem gift-wrapped looking block pillars took the cake. Both queens, while adopting a still posture on stage started to look statuesque themselves several times. Having the Elisabetta of Katie van Kooten perched, standing upon high pedestal for her first aria proved stilted, obnoxious. Joyce di Donato descending a plain metal rolled on staircase seemed hardly less clumsy.

Most routiniere however were the musical results for what some of us might have reckoned an important revival here. Maria Stuarda, from near the very beginning, has not had the happiest performance history on record, neither that nor quite a recorded legacy up to what this work deserves. For starters, the orchestral writing reveals Donizetti at his very best at it, composed for orchestra at Naples (though premiered at La Scala) that under Rossini’s eight years there had further established a fine reputation. Seeking out how to emulate the meditative tone of the Schiller tragedy, on which this opera is based, this is the most inward looking of actually Donizetti’s four Tudor queen operas (the other being Il castello di Kenilworth). What love interest gets explored in Maria Stuarda is of limited scope, and not very convincing.

The title role is written in a slightly but noticeably lower tessitura than other Donizetti heroines – as having been written for Giuseppina Ronzi de Begnis (though created by Maria Malibran), a famous Donna Anna, Norma and also Rosina (Barbiere) of her day. Imaginatively, the finale (Aria del Supplizio) for Maria, to the opera as well is comprised of two major slow sections, eschewing the brilliance of other aria finales of the era. It has only been fairly recently, outside Italy, that this work and its merits have become more deeply appreciated.

Most notably Janet Baker and now Joyce di Donato have further revealed how tempting the title role, with its slightly atypically low tessitura is for mezzos to sing. Interpolating high notes, even while transposing much material for Maria down alternatively a half and whole step, di Donato managed with ease. Di Donato indeed sounded compelling during her opening aria “O nube che lieve”, taken a half-step down, sung with a lightly inflected mezza voce, including good trills. Its melodic line anticipates “Des quells transports” from Don Carlos for Maria’s friend Elisabeth de Valois and Carlos; both are in D-Flat Major, each in context of prevailing C Major overall And this happens likely to similar psychological effect – of reliance upon some delusion to maintain good peace of mind.

Although similarly floated phrases occurred elsewhere, some awkwardness of approaching Maria as a mezzo became unavoidable – but hardly so for an aging Janet Baker thirty years ago – as emulated by di Donato early on and employing all the very same transpositions down Baker had. Affectation of humility at start of ‘Dialogue’ with Elisabetta Di Donato handled well, as also her rage spilling over during same developing confrontation. Di Donato’s agility for this music is mostly secure; her mastery of other facets of her vocalism though is subject to doubt.

One expects more suppleness for role of Maria Stuarda than for Elisabetta. Di Donato sang Elisabetta in Geneva five years ago - very successfully. Lately though, even with valiant effort to achieve a free and light soprano top, some tonal hardness, stiffness has developed around the break – evident here, plus curiously bland middle register. Pitch accuracy intermittently also became problematic. More audible from di Donato today too are shifts between registers, tendency almost to aspirate phrase openings. With partial attempt to rein in and relax the chest voice, legato also gets compromised.

Vulnerability of this beleaguered queen of did not fully register. Light red dress attire further underlined some lack of nobility during final scene(s). Such qualities seemed more run aground by leaving exposed technical hurdles, encompassing Maria’s florid lines, moreover by a generic countenance and approach to this character together with her music. Ultimately, pathos regarding Maria’s plight did not quite seize the day, perhaps for di Donato being of customary (post-)modern mindset of needing to fit in.

Matching cardboard quality of the sets was the unstable Elisabetta of Katie van Kooten, quite effective an Ellen Orford in recent Peter Grimes here. Van Kooten here however sounded out of her element. For starters, while being incisive with certainly well understood text, her vocal production seldom came across Italianate. Considerable push and strain at achieving spinto tone - agility only mildly compromised - damaged tone quality, from weak low notes, through vinegary tone in-between to shrill top - some squall right beneath. Van Kooten especially sounded heavily miked at the Wortham; the resulting harshly bright metallic effect downstairs verged on ear-splitting. Her highly questionable intonation then seemed irrelevant.

This Elisabetta, all very two-dimensional, came up then very short on noble bearing – hardly then seeming of any real power with which to reckon. Van Kooten managed to restore Elisabetta some composure, warmer legato for several lines starting Act Three – hardly sufficient to make up for much else.

Leicester, musically written well, seldom becomes dramatically effective. In Geneva, opposite a cold, but fully rounded Elisabetta of di Donato, Eric Cutler stood his ground as a musically even, gracious, deferential Leicester - of naturally drier resources than several other tenors. This go-around he opted to wear his heart on his sleeve. Like Stephen Costello (Dallas’s Leicester in 2007) as Percy in the Met’s Anna Bolena recently, Cutler made the very epitome, with much bleating, of a kicked puppy as Leicester. Pleading Third Act duet with Elisabetta became most embarrassing. There were still lines remindful of Geneva, his fine Tamino here four years ago too, but not supplying the prevailing impression this time.

Catherine Martin somewjhat too briefly supplied a warm, steadying presence as Anna. Oren Gradus contrasted well his dark-toned, slightly worn sounding Lord Cecil, while demonstrating fine bearing, with Talbot of Robert Gleadow. Gleadow appeared sympathetic, ingratiating, musically conscientious, with lower register dry, then reticent for filling out some of Talbot’s lines.

For his fourth Donizetti piece here, Patrick Summers conducted. From an authentic practice perspective, also of what bel canto conventions establish, Summers demonstrated some understanding here. However, sense of real aesthetic encompassing such a work, also of especially how Maria Stuarda breaks free of convention, came across only tepid, and therein exists the challenge. Inhibitions his singers encountered were likely partly due to a frequently stiff, unyielding beat. Places to make various forms of accelerando, piu mosso, frequently came across jerky, choppy - not inculcated well into overall flowing line. Fawning over particular lines from di Donato eventually sounded contrived. Grandeur, solemnity implicit to two important Third Act choruses (the Preghiera included) sounded short-changed

Extensive numerous cuts, many of them to repeats, became customary. Clipping of phrasing, rhythms undercut, in addition to extensive cut therein, dramatic stretta finale to Act Two to point of sounding frivolous. Clpping also occurring during highly theatrical dialogue between two queens central to three-part demarcated finale to Act Two made the dramatic apex of Maria Stuarda merely virtual diminution thereof. Similarity to Lucia arises in that similar sextets open both Act Two finales. What desperation and nastiness di Donato and Van Kooten could muster - also generating annoying audience laughter downstairs due to weak buildup to such a big moment – helped rescue this episode.

Much want of grandeur, of rich color and intricacy Donizetti made substantiate such remained to the end, seldom got satiated. Here we had Maria Stuarda made diminutive, auspiciously minimized – upon special occasion of its HGO debut.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Thursday, April 19, 2012

HGO: 1886 Don Carlos (plus 1867 extracts) performed in Houston for first time in French. Patrick Summers. John Caird.15.4.12.



In 1985 DGG released first ever commercial Don Carlos – French 1886 version conducted by Claudio Abbado, starring Placido Domingo among a mostly Italian cast. Appendix includes ballet plus five other Paris extracts (1866) Verdi soon removed and did not replace. Most popular option recently should any of this get inserted – even if only following 1866 - Carlos’s angry declamation and Carlos-Philippe duet together following death of Posa appears as only one among above-mentioned extracts.

At the time the Abbado got released, specialized press mentioned 1972 BBC concert rendition (now on four Opera Rara discs – 2006 release) of the complete 1866 version (erroneously labeled 1867 for year of Paris world premiere). In-between we’ve had Pappano’s Paris recording /dvd (very preferable not only for its being in French to recent Pappano at Convent Garden) – though this Don Carlos edition-wise a mishmash.

At least the Pappano did not claim near as much as has Houston Grand Opera for what they just put on at the Wortham. Neither did Welsh National Opera, when John Caird’s production first opened there. Rodney Milnes, in Opera (U.K.) credits it as having been the 1886 revision with restoration of Paris extracts implanted back in (excluding the ballet) including Carlos-Philippe duet ”cannibalized for the Requiem” (Milnes). This is curious; as of 1867 neither any requiem was in the works, involving Verdi, nor had impetus for one arisen yet. Recall of Milnes’s comment almost compelled me - Cai Mingbo, fine assistant at founding this blog, can testify - to input some error here; having Julian Budden on hand then fortuitously intervened.


As recently as 2005, Milnes esteemed both getting Don Carlos performed in French, and circumspectly how (implied) ‘Paris extracts’ got restored as each “a heroic act;” perhaps so. Houston Grand Opera has claimed to have taken things further. ‘Original’ as in ‘original version’ shows up eight times in Houston Chronicle preview of Don Carlos, then ‘authentic’ twice. Had this been twenty-plus years ago, a near fully synonymous claim could still be responsibly made for much of what transpired here. Restoring the 1866 or 1867 edition might then have been reckoned venture arcane or recondite, not to mention procuring corresponding orchestral parts, expense involved. It however this past decade is fait accompli, just not as of yet in Houston, Texas. What got played here instead was entirely 1886 - plus (almost) four interpolations from 1866-67,

‘Trims’ occurred outside of what “we knew Verdi wanted to take out” – Summers adding to how Verdi might “wield the knife”, despite much sanctimonious espousal of Verdi’s wishes. One can surmise the 1886 Don Carlo might only be based upon a ‘rushed’ Italian translation. Perhaps the Italian did get rushed, but what then have we had here? The music was clearly 1886, lest anybody one day become incredulous at true ‘original version’ that before chronologically John Matheson, Ingo Metzmacher, Bertrand de Billy, and Maurizio Benini have conducted - latter three at major European houses – and with it in French.. De Billy (Vienna) is available on both compact disc and dvd. Revisions from the ‘original’ French, the historical record asserts, became laborious between Verdi and surviving French librettists (a temporarily offended Camille du Locle, then as auxiliary, Charles Nuitter). Du Locle and Joseph Mery were the original librettists.

Heavy cuts got taken to banda scored music during the auto-da-fe, alongside staging-wise (as even Houston Press claims) selling short grandeur of both music and spectacle therein. No version, as occurred here, authorizes Act Three to begin with Carlos’s ‘”A Minuit” (“E mezzanotte” - recitative). 1884 haunting orchestral prelude makes sole alternative to exchange-of-veils duet for female leads to open Act Three.

Cut of ‘magical’ twenty-plus seconds with which to conclude “Des quels transports” (duet) remains inscrutable. Youtube snippet on HGO’s website early made me aware of this, thus it had me apprehend dastardly cut of “L’heure fatale est sonnee” (just past Thibault’s interjections at Fontainebleau about fateful shift in plans), then of ‘O prodige” from Act Two duet; fortunately my fears were unfounded. Quasi-Gounod high wind scoring at Fontainebleau ‘magical’ to Budden might inhibit Summers – music out of sync with lofty 1886 passages or anachronistic with Verdi’s ‘Wagnerian aspirations.’ Verdi, perhaps benightedly, always declined to cut any of this passage himself.

Verdi’s ‘Wagnerisms’ have become lofty considerations at one local corner of the blogosphere. Oddly enough, doing the 1866 or 1867 version straight (latter without Carlos-Philippe duet), with freedom to cut all the ballet, might most comfortably fit Summers’s more natural predilections. Not however with Verdi’s aspirations to Wagnerian ideals might then such a decision adequately take to Verdi’s loftier instincts, mind you, his desire to compose like Richard Wagner. Even in mind of many later improvements to have transpired, case now fully suffices for doing, even unabridged, the flexible, frequently stylistically consistent original version.

John Caird’s production, heavily set (Johan Engels) with pervasive Cross motif, is glibly noir, second tier melodramatic. Neon magenta lit crosses adorn bleachers on both sides on monotonous unit design for closing scenes. Some lassitude or malaise fills space where any physical action seems very unlikely. Previn’s “Brief Vacation” (2009 - Caird’s HGO debut) was much easier for him than has been Don Carlos.

Interaction between characters, their ability, inability to connect, looked stiff. Eye contact between lovers at Fontainebleau was weak. Situating Carlos and Elisabeth at opposite corners of outspread heavy sheet indecisively set stage for their Act Two duet Carlos outstretching his hands to compel Elisabeth near turned haunting portion of final rendezvous completely banal.. Lighting (Nigel Livings) was equally off, i.e. spectral night opening Act Two gardens (with web shadowing of obsessive Cross design).

With benign consequences certainly unlikely on one occasion, violence on stage was something, with no trace of irony to anything, to seemingly occur at random, i.e. how could Rodrigue in Act Two get away with starting to turn brief altercation with Philippe physical? Carlos being thrown to stage floor by guards to open the prison scene was gratuitous, all off in intonation with simple gravitas with which Verdi opens this scene. Intimations of torture, tight confinement of inmates towards stage rear began to resemble something lifted from Monty Python - as did quasi-KKK decked Inquisitor to enter all the way on stage to run Rodrigue through, then to very similarly dispatch Carlos at the very end – in case we missed how previous impaling got carried out.

Certainly risible was the major confrontation during the auto-da-fe scene Contemporarily decked out guards had their machine guns trained, for Carlos to then, not apprehended, armed with just one long sword, challenge the King. Even with Carlos having just turned over his weapon, these guards still then rush off, leaving madman free behind. (Spirit of) Charles V, open ugly sarcophagus thereof both blocking access to stage rear at the end contradicted more than Carlos being slain itself (from which some escape could still perhaps occur) final pronouncement by the mysterious friar. Quick procession of monks across the footlights to help start Act Two also looked awkward.

Rampant emotionalism further emphasized a pervasive lack of irony and lack of trust for one’s audience. Thoroughly diminished was tone to illuminate themes explored here - with any subtle sense of what complexity is involved. Anybody having attended Fidelio last fall could not have honestly received much of this Don Carlos well.

Brandon Jovanovich made his role debut as Don Carlos. Positive before here as Turiddu, in Austin as Sergei (Lady Macbeth of Mtsensk – Texas premiere), and as Boris in Kat’a Kabanova in Chicago, the awkwardness of Verdi’s writing and anonymous character of the staging especially affecting his part effaced him here. French diction sounded mildly coagulated, tone often curdled in negotiating everything. A handsome, affable presence on stage, even while matters improved vocally for him as the evening wore on, ultimately proved less than sufficiently decisive. This engagement resembled more (temporarily) a miscasting than it did any worrisome sign of vocal decline.

Tamara Wilson returned here for her second major Verdi role; her Ballo Amelia several seasons back proved very heavy sailing. Her sympathetic countenance was pleasant – if as though a wallflower perhaps. Up though until the last two acts, musical results proved tenuous. Farewell to Countess of Aremberg emerged all beneath pitch. Tremulous passsaggio, beneath freely floating top was evident, habits also to reach low notes from above and to swallow consonants. Wilson’s gift for lyric Verdi became clear during Act Four, then for securely spun out Act Five aria, with fine expressive legato.

Christine Goeke, to qualified success, made her role debut as Eboli. Veil Song sounded unnaturally heavy, dark, and sour with intonation. She then developed into an incisive tigress of an Eboli for trios in Act Three, and then blended well with Wilson for rarely sung “J’ai tout compris” in Act Four. With much savvy and ringing top Goeke robustly commanded the stage for “O don fatal.” Loading the stage with ladies-in-waiting of considerable girth for her opening scene did not favorably complement having both Wilson and Goeke on stage together moments later.

Two looking most committed to this production, partly from having sung this at Cardiff in 2005 were Scott Hendricks and Andrea Silvestrelli. They also proved the musically and arguably histrionically the most lacking. Hendricks offered mild hope early on he might tone down playing Rodrigue too proletariat. Act Two romance emerged unattractively dry, but tastefully. Much hectoring, forcing then held sway during long duologue with Philippe. Rude manhandling of Eboli made Hendricks, with his costuming, resemble having just walked on off set design for Il Tabarro. Prison scene, especially an overacted “O Carlos, ecoute” emerged graceless, hectored, non legato.

Silvestrelli made a bludgeoning, quite unmitigated ruffian of a Philippe, frequently out of tune. His voice carries very well, but proved inflexible handling sixteenths admonishing Flemish deputies during the auto-da-fe. Raising jewelry box to close “Elle ne m’aime pas”, then to shove it in Elisabeth’s face to begin their confrontation together looked sophomoric; climax out of inevitable insult got derailed. Motivation to deeply probe the king’s frustrations though remained clear.

Rhetorically overpowering Silvestrelli was the Grand Inquisitor of, at seventy, Samuel Ramey, uniquely revealing sterling command of the stage plus alacritous sense of where the king’s vulnerabilities, curiosities, close ties lie. Ramey can be seen from La Scala (1993), holding forth there very authoritatively as Philippe (as with here eight years later) – with Silvestrelli very responsibly cast as the Friar. Ramey’s voice and ever unflinching countenance here emerged steady, firmly implacable. Mark Diamond (Forester), Boris Dyakov (De Lerma), plus a vivacious Lauren Snouffer as Tebaldo stood up to very eloquently represent Houston Opera Studio, plus longstanding HOS alumnus in an ever sonorous Oren Gradus (Friar).

When Patrick Summers conducted Don Carlo here eleven years ago, his stick technique looked tentative, but he was more circumspect for task at hand then. Emilio Sagi’s production provided him wholesome perspectival depth, fine illusion of grandeur, if abstractly, to much better couch or envelope what emanated from the orchestra pit plus all around than, for instance, something halfway resembling Broadway could do so. Sense of continuity throughout was fine, but also tendency to rush through passages needing more shape or nuance - to avoid brash sounding brass during Veil Song ritornelli, then for soloists to expand out on their lines (during “Si l’on repand encore” refrain to Elisabeth’s last aria - very strictly calibrated its light barcarolle accompaniment through its reprise). Very cool streamlining of royal couple’s entrance at San Just significantly undercut grandeur obvious there. Calibration between pit and stage notably slipped during getting slightly rushed the Third Act Flemish deputies’ concertato.

Solo oboes, trumpets sounded unfocussed; Barrett Sills’ cello solo starting Act Four was eloquent. Summers showed some lyrical ear for color within the Act Two duet - partly missing subtle change in tinta for ‘O prodige’ over gilding so much - approach that also dragged “J’ai tout compris” (Act Four Elisabeth-Eboli duet). Tone overall elsewhere started to sound anemic; choral work was less than up to expected ensemble standards (from Richard Bado). Summers proved quite adept though in achieving proper scale through most of Act Four Some affinity for Don Carlos also became evident during ‘Fontainebleau’ – also toward building fine atmosphere with which to open next scene at San Just. Pervasive sense of grandeur still seemed lacking from equation overall.

In order to de-cannibalize portions of Don Carlos, we should next assign George Romero to stage this. The ‘smoked’ (not quite fully immolated) heretics could walk off the pyre, then later stalk their persecutors toward the end of Act Four. Plot outcome might change somewhat even as might tempt Peter Konwitschny, to frighten traditionalists more, but they lost faith in him a long time ago anyway. Some other blogger previewing our production got caught up with discussing self-immolations, their making a comeback - as inspired by many Tibetans protesting oppression abroad. Some of the socio-political message of Don Carlos has certainly remained timeless until now, just as has that of Beethoven’s Fidelio. For sole unabridged ‘original’ Don Carlos on dvd, the De Billy/Konwtischny from Vienna (2004 - Arthaus), starring Ramon Vargas (Don Carlo – HGO 2001), staging included, comes highly recommend.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , ,

Thursday, February 9, 2012

HGO: Rape of Lucretia (debut). Striking, elusive finale to Britten series. Michelle De Young. Rory McDonald. Arin Arbus.

Houston Grand Opera has just opened its first formal staging of Benjamin Britten’s first chamber opera, Rape of Lucretia - written shortly after first real lyric stage success, Peter Grimes. The image of Lucretia, all ramifications of heroism, sacrifice implied, captured the imagination of many artists, painters - also inspiring earlier musical settings. Britten and his librettist, Ronald Duncan, looked to Andre Obey’s play, Le Viol de Lucrece, as their source. Partly due to toll war took on resources, Britten decided to write here then for smaller forces. His ear, already adept toward making sonorities of chamber music delicacy come to life, meant that choice this way contributed only little to his operating at somewhat of a strain here. His having to deal with dramaturgically difficult subject matter, static character thereof, plus difficult and verbose librettist contributed more this way. Toward keeping Rape of Lucretia viable work of art, Britten made psychological use of growing tonal palette ultimately toward making something elusive, distanced thus his setting of this story to music.

Michelle DeYoung, very successful Brangane at both Met and La Scala quite recently, played the title role. Anthony Dean Griffey, after successful rendition of Peter Grimes here last season, provided Male Chorus. Rory McDonald, apprenticing recently under Antonio Pappano (Royal Opera), made with Rape of Lucretia, his HGO debut, replacing Patrick Summers on relatively short notice, due one guesses apparently to administrative backlog pressing upon Summers nowadays. Arin Arbus, in her HGO debut, though little experienced in opera thus far, revealed good theatrical and aesthetic sense, all in part product of making healthy inquiry regarding this art form. Far better is this than conceit of producers too self-assured not to regard as first and foremost repertoire they will stage - instead of contribution they reckon primarily important.

Andre Obey relates Lucretia’s suicide as instrumental toward cleansing what corruption which prince Tarquinus’s wanton act has inflicted upon Rome. Loss to the Etruscans of tyrannical hegemony over Rome five centuries before Christ quickly became inevitable. For message Britten seeks to convey, political considerations get relegated well to the background. Duncan, Britten’s librettist, hardly compelling advocate for brevity, saw Lucretia’s suicide sufficient with which to end the piece. Britten however, not for musical purposes alone, perceived the need to less abruptly, thinly frame such incident. Inclusion of Christian symbolism, most of all dealing with the death of Christ, served for Britten clear purpose – universalized figure thus thereof superior at personifying atonement, sacrifice central to natural internalization of guilt, then on behalf of excusing the actions of others.

Breaking things down more, Britten as Clare Seymour has explaied, was not primarily interested in gender relations near as much as issue to do with the act of seduction itself, and division between pure beauty or chastity and desire or lust. In perceiving happenings among heterosexuals, some homosexual ideation certainly comes into play - eventually toward linking Lucretia with Billy Budd, Aschenbach in Death in Venice – considerable task to fully decode, elucidate. Otherness about Lucretia does not much emerge on the surface such as with antihero Peter Grimes. She is already viable leader in her community, blending in well, clearly unlike Grimes. Suicide in the Britten becomes her means to absorb some of the guilt involved for action in which she is truly innocent. Lucretia subconsciously, half consciously to us, significantly draws Tarquinius in, ultimately toward compromising, threatening her still worse. Tarquinius, less intriguing to Britten than Lucretia, has an undeniable passivity, also as depicted musically, even while turning violent. Junius, practical sidekick of his early on in Act One, is practically Tarquinius wannabe, and experiences similar drives but conscience restrained from ever (ideally) fulfilling them. All men, especially while at drink, are equally liable to getting drawn in thus, similar to Tarquinius. Unblemished feminine beauty, purity is, interpreted here, further incitement to lust. Quintuplet figures, representing Lucretia, litter the score, abundantly fill out extended vocal lines.

Mirroring between agent(s) and recipients of seduction became impetus, engine behind how Bob Carsen staged Mozart’s Don Giovanni at La Scala two months ago – some of which blocked by excessive infusion of additives - device, obsessing over such. Such device thus often became front and center, obstructing attention from action on stage and music to portray such, drive action forward, fill out either normally expected or surprised emotional reaction. What can obstruct maintaining healthy focus with Lucretia is the excessively verbose libretto of Ronald Duncan, deleteriously empowered thus, should one opt for an excessively purist or pristine either musical or dramatic approach.

Decision by Ariin Arbus and Rory McDonald, working in fine tandem was, if to err, to err then on the side of simplicity. Musical rewards, with taking such an approach, became abundant, in drawing out Britten’s rich, even if chamber forces subdued tonal palette. One can not draw out of twelve players, regardless how fine, what atmospheric compass, sweep Peter Grimes almost automatically provides.

Michelle DeYoung, enjoying first HGO visit since playing Venus in Tannhauser ten years ago, made a healthily voluptuous Lucretia, physically and vocally. She, though, for spinning scene first entrance, showed prudence to restrain opening out too much, thus revealing how internally aware Lucretia is of her station in life. Arioso, ‘How cruel men are” incisively evinced firm moral reproach, anticipating well taut response to Tarquinius’s assault - latter with defining moment, expressed darkly, incisively, ‘You, In the forest of my dreams.’ Anxiety, urgency expressed during garden scene was firm, distraught – but also while evoking hysteria for production to turn mildly blowsy, putting Lucretia’s value upon pure marital bliss slightly subject to doubt. The more pristine Brit approach might convey more authority – though leaving behind doubt of Lucretia’s ability to draw Tarquinius in. Two ringing acuti comfortably above the break distinguished one or two tense passages. Fine poise, dignity characterized much DeYoung contributed, even if perhaps quasi-verismo in approach at times.

Character contrast between Lucretia’s maidservants was abundant, between Lauren Snouffer’s pert, gracefully charming Lucia with alternatively light and clarion ringing top and Judith Forst’s earthily conscientious Bianca. A little fraying at the edges vocally became evident here from Forst. After stellar appearances in Turn of the Screw and Pique-Dame here two seasons ago. Gutsy urgency toward delaying, preventing Collatinus’s arrival in Act Two was telling. Forst, still conveying much ring of authority with text and all-knowing look on stage seldom seemed seriously encumbered by any vocal considerations. Leah Crocetto, with voice seemingly hybrid between mezzo and soprano, well conveyed look of moral authority, strong witness as Female Chorus, but toward higher reaches in the part mildly squally in tone and diction. Crocetto matched Griffey mostly well in unisons together and strutted forth in firm chest voice, with taut chutzpah marcia of ‘So here the grumbling Romans’ - memorably so. Additional lines within similarly confident reach also well got message across.

Contrast between sparring trio of in effect frat boys Collatinus, Junius, and Tarquinius, all quite similarly voiced here was at first, perhaps on purpose, hard to pick out. Ryan McKinny provided fine swagger, suave line, and in final scene with Lucretia, well attenuated empathy as Collatinus, if slightly lacking full tonal depth toward limning general’s lines more authoritatively. Guileless sense, naivete regarding what Lucretia might become up against elucidated well where perhaps some of Lucretia’s vulnerability may lie. Joshua Hopkins made ideal match vocally for Junius, capturing identifiably well the lad’s conscience stricken frustration restraining him from Tarquinius like conquest of Lucretia himself - almost always otherwise one seemingly merry, guileless lad. Jacques Imbralio, 2007 Cardiff finalist for auspicious HGO debut, with finest diction and phrasing of this lot, made earlier taunting, then suavely lascivious, ultimately consumed Tarquinius – with almost unrivalled fun and aplomb from amidst gang of three.

Thoroughly splendid was Male Chorus of Anthony Dean Griffey, providing illusion of this part being as dramatically engaged as, played eloquently here by Griffey before, Lennie and Peter Grimes. Diction - equally fine Imbrailo’s - was so distinctive, suavely conveyed that if not warned beforehand, hardly would it be credible that Griffey isn’t British. He made perfectly musical, astutely alert all spoken line anticipating Tarquinius’s approach to Lucretia’s inner chambers. Enveloping honeyed melos for stretching out lyricism was always at the ready to make point as specific as with furious reproach – nothing ever cloying. Some mystery remains how none of this conspicuously verbose part never seemed one line too long. If only Wagner could have made Gurnemanz a lyric tenor! Bravura for vocalized ‘ride to Rome’ interlude (Act One) was salaciously complete. Solo framing line (to unison of both choruses) such as ‘Christ, heal our blindness we mistake for sight’ hovered far beyond the footlights toward conveying universally extended balm, sublime bliss.

Arin Arbus, upon relatively simple set framed by Roman columns and steps, discreetly adorned by brick, stone, and garment (Jean-Guy Lecat), with named characters in traditional garb, Choruses in modern, displayed fine discretion and flexibility in drawing out fine, well nuanced realism from all cast members on stage. Interaction from Choruses with characters, first situated in-between, reckoned entirely well when to lend climactic stations during narrative in progress good, meaningful emphasis. Lighting (Michael James Clark) through dark chiaroscuro for night scenes, bright sunlight to enhance pastel colors on stage, pastels as well from the orchestra pit, fine half-lit silhouetting of Roman characters anathematizing the Etruscans was of very high quality toward providing both sonic and visual picture fuller body.

Rory McDonald provided fine leadership, making all overlap of contrasting, frequently suggestive sonorities flow well, rhythmic life and emphasis pulsating within. Lightly harp adorned muted strings provided night scenes fine patina thus. Duet of alto flute and clarinet helped provide warm down into which to sink, while making intimate distinction of Crocetto’s poetic lullaby for Lucretia asleep on stage. More stringent accents characterized spiky, steadily ‘Chorus’ led chorale prelude interlude framing traumatic action on stage having just transpired, then firmly held in check, magisterial passacaglia finale to entire work. Bach Passion inspired obbligato by Elisabeth Priestly Knight on English horn to elaborate simply intoned lament between Lucretia and Collatinus was highly expressive.

While evoking fine scale for this work’s elusive proportions, McDonald made enfold contrasting pastels and darker sharp keys – latter especially evoking knowledge Britten likely picked up from Verdi. Flow between contrasting passages - consoling solace for sleeping Lucretia, encroaching, seemingly ubiquitous menace occurred seamlessly, unimpeded – all as though peeling back contrasting, revealing layers of consciousness. McDonald only trusted slightly too much stewardship provided percussion - some tendency toward over-emphasis, helping clot several nodal points - lines to tightly rein all in becoming cramped instead. Insightful though, McDonald’s attitude well manifest toward modernism here was unflinching. McDonald should return here soon - eventually for well-varied repertoire.

Sadly then and quite elusively, HGO’s Britten cycle has drawn slightly early to a close. It opened with Billy Budd in 2008, providing single installment all four seasons since. Gloriana was next season to provide grandiose finale to this always superbly probing illuminating series. Audience response to this shorter piece – arguably most elusive and difficult thus far - was highly favorable, suggesting perhaps that HGO soon take on still more challenging progressive repertoire from this past century – with hope for improvement to orchestral forces toward achieving worthiness for such assignment.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , ,

Sunday, November 6, 2011

HGO Fidelio: Wild, unqualified triumph marking heroic return of Karita Mattila - Met production revival (Jurgen Flimm). Michael Hofstetter. 05.11.11.

Common sports lingo might deem this having really hit one out of the park. Such could be very accurate in assessing Houston Grand Opera’s first production now of Beethoven’s Fidelio in twenty-six years. At somewhat an intuitive level, this Fidelio quickly near its outset and for numerous passages to follow had a way of leading its own way - working out by what even to whomever naïve appeared to follow a certain inscrutable and inexorable logic.

One major contributing factor was certainly HGO’s hosting of celebrated producer Jurgen Flimm - in production we borrowed from the Metropolitan Opera. BBC broadcast of Flimm's production ran last summer from London, starring a mildly tentative Nina Stemme and mediocre Florestan - Endrick Wottrich notorious for dissing Pierre Boulez, accompanying producer for their controversial, most interesting recent Parsifal together at Bayreuth. For casting deficiency or two and last minute need to replace on podium Kirill Petrenko with Mark Elder, things did not quite mesh, catch fire as readily as they did at the Wortham Center the Saturday evening, third performance, of this run.

Leads for HGO’s run on this occasion were Karita Mattila and Simon O’Neill. In 1985 they had been Hildegard Behrens and worthy of special note, the underrated Polish tenor Wieslaw Ochman – from whom eighteen months later we picked up a most suavely neurotic Herod – part somebody should have definitely made him record to supplement his Narraboth’s for Bohm and Karajan. Karita Mattila last appeared here in 2006 for Manon Lescaut - with cool Nordic penetrating tone, delivery scoring a considerable vocal and histrionic triumph then.

From several moments into time curtain was up on opening singspiel scene to Fidelio, one could sense something already in the air – even with just merely HGO studio member and returning alumnus Brittany Wheeler (Marzelline) and Norman Reinhardt (Jaquino) on stage, preoccupied as much as their habitual sparring conversation for the day as with polishing the jail office’s firearms arsenal. All, through Marzelline’s aria expressing her perplexity with conflicting romantic entanglements, came across with fine melos and charm without ever stepping over line to turn anything cloying. Especially anybody slightly more than casually familiar with Flimm’s work could pick up his very close manner of having prepared his cast to draw both his audience in and singers amongst themselves. Kristinn Sigmundsson, both figure and voice of ample girth on stage, played a very warm, convivial Rocco, achieving for later more dramatic scenes all on verge of fine gravitas for crucial interaction therein and genuine compassion for leading protagonists (and also never insipidly cowering fear of offending Pizarro).

Hard to locate, highly underrated Nozze di Figaro Flimm staged for Zurich reveals how – in close-up upon simple change of countenance turn to internal strand of the plot can be forced to happen, as though on a dime. Contrast this, if you will, with excess clutter accompanied heavy mug and blither while not blank feel characterizing David McVicar’s over-rated production of Le Nozze. There is more sexual, dramatic. musical tension on cusp of exploding between Eva Mei and Rodney Gilfry – partly for effort to have dropped many useless clichés – than to be seen the other night between a glib, blank-faced Anna Bolena and good Enrico VIII from the Met.

The very fine Falk Struckmann provided Pizaaro sinister mature weight for Met incarnation of Flimm’s production nine seasons back, vis-à-vis notably youthful, almost naively visionary appearing Rocco of Rene Pape. Dynamic between these two shifted for Houston Grand Opera now between Tomas Tomasson (Tomsky - Pique-Dame, 2010) and Sigmundsson. One might detect a little of suavely delivered (and vocalized) proto-Scarpia aspects of Rodney Gilfry’s brilliant portrayal of Almaviva in Tomasson’s Pizarro. With slightly gravelly voice, but determined line, forza infused encompassing of wide range, here was the picture of blind, youthfull choleric ambition, handsomely packaged – dangerously at the ready to close the sale toward dispatching of Florestan – and then eventually anyone else in his way. Such dynamic again between these two may have garbed itself in more conventional format than at the Met, it seemed, but really at only one end of running dialogue – and equally compellingly. Struckmann and Pape always remain a hard act to follow.

Striking contrast to the villainy of Pizarro, an equally dapper looking Kyle Ketelsen provided Don Fernando’s closing weighty benediction with fine shape and profile, artistically meriting equal approval from the hall – even almost as though unawares of sinister goings-on surrounding rear scaffolding – deep clouds hovering above – purposefully clearer and more disturbing to visual and dramatic perspective than as seen on digital video (dvd).

With even dramatic shift of power, even seemingly into the right hands, element in society can still persist toward trying to recover its way or holding of sway – perhaps more potently now than before – and as realized here also a little more violently – completely without overkill. Witness the sometimes arbitrary police berating of Occupy Wall Street, related protesters across our own fair land. So well articulated in having both Pizarro and Fernando both decked out in three-piece suits, is timeless long by now – since robber baron, wealthy bureaucrat decked out giants and gods respectively of Patrice Chereau’s Ring – oh, not to mention how efficiently laptop, fax machine, water cooler accommodated Alan Titus’s Wotan was for Flimm at Bayreuth two decades later. Very efficient timelessly modernized sett design (Robert Israel) in deep browns and grays, wall of tiered cells distinctively to the right with arms sticking out plus costuming (Florence van Gerkan) and lighting (Duane Schuler) were spot-on.

Couched by the fine simplicity driven musical leadership of Hofstetter, honed to near perfection all evening long - delivered with sufficient weight - long passionate high G from (visually) darkness enshrouded Florestan of Simon O’Neill starting his opening Act Two monologue rang out with compelling force and projection, but leading into fine shaping, encompassing of well nuanced lyricism of the part as well. For more dramatic utterances, O’Neill’s tone is not found the most ingratiating, but the certainty and ferocity of his delivery was sufficient to perhaps recall sometimes a hardly more tonally ingratiating James King on a good night as Florestan. The feel he provided for imploring Fidelio and Rocco for remote chance to see Leonore, his wife, again, through both spoken dialogue and song became deeply moving here.

Helping alongside Flimm and Hofstetter stitch all together was the magnetic Leonore of Karita Mattila, at first sighting stumbling onto stage carrying bag of groceries – as though still learning the steps of being a boy – but then this time perhaps bailing on daily potassium intake; perhaps Wortham Center pantry backstage or distributor was short on supply of bananas. Perhaps a Jurgen Flimm Wozzeck brought up to date, selenium or quercetin intake delivered or sitting around might also come handy – but then Wozzeck’s rage might turn out less violent and then the play would no longer be the same. (I could not help tonight but note Flimm’s place of birth being Giessen – site of Buchner’s alma mater).

Fidelio marked heroic return by Mattila to the Wortham Center stage. Shift of registers, making reach for high notes, sustaining line up to them is all such for which she has lost a little ease during the past several years. Within picture of quietly intense, flexible shaping of all that occurred here, depth of feel, perspective Flimm provided – Mattila recovered some of the above with fine malleability, color, flexibility, even some of the bloom of former years.

Between Mattila and Flimm, this Fidelio proved how great stage direction, production of opera requires a good ear on part of the producer - in addition to on part of who may be conducting. With Mattila fully understanding, encompassing very compelled, commanding line, filling much subtle nuance therein – through the challenging hurdles of ‘Komm, Hoffnung’ and elsewhere – dramatic impetus Beethoven’s music opens out, compels forward became complete, filling out all Fidelio is about. This was work matching highest current international standards for both directing and singing Fidelio – and especially from Karita Mattila, both always looking very comfortable in her own skin and thus filling out Leonore with most magnetic, engaged self-effacing warmth. One could not help but be moved.

Why much mention of Wozzeck above? One might guess and very reasonably that part of Marie Met – could figure before long within Karita Mattila’s sights. Given all the dramatic excitement happening on stage, the classic grosse pause Alban Berg parodied during Act One seduction scene thereof got slightly over-stepped here. There is still opportunity to ameliorate matters, fully recover the mother of all dramatic pauses in music history – to supplement good handful of pregnant, dramatically rife pauses interjecting earlier dialogue, interaction. Apart from that, Hofstetter, in pacing Fidelio, flexibly filling out its lyricism very seldom put a foot wrong. Mild prudence accommodating one or two slightly strained voices during Act Two may have slightly undercut dramatic tension, quasi-period abrupt accent or two may have slightly broken line - churlish to mention any of this.

Choral preparation (Richard Bado) is still fine, yet in this context I intermittently found several lines during Prisoner’s Chorus slightly louder in volume than might provide most moving results. Note however the hush, spaciousness with which Hofstetter infused slowly ascending strings to implore men sideways – and then prudent spacing, weight provided, underpinning them throughout and through sometimes aimless extending out through through-composed dialogue to follow –everybody’s attention rapt instead – toward poised, gently drifting off conclusion to Act One. Luminous warmth, achieved by HGO orchestra winds, alacrity infused witty pointing of opening singspiel, anticipatorily hushed Act One quartet (‘Mir ist wunderbar’) and highly spirited uplift infused finale to Fidelio marked Hofstetter’s return as very compelling (since good 2008 Beatrice et Benedict – featuring excellent Benedict of Norman Reinhardt) – always toward very clear goals in mind. He should soon get invited back.

This Fidelio is such necessity to go see, should anyone reading this be in the area - anything no longer important months, years later can get put aside for this opportunity. Houston Grand Opera has scored an unqualified triumph this week. Certainly for local yokels but perhaps for visitors from away to reckon HGO entity of true international standing - was occasion to feel very fortunate to be alive to witness this.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , ,

Wednesday, February 9, 2011

HGO - Youth informs both vocal leads, podium for Lucia di Lammermoor in abstract new production. Albina Shagimuratova. 05.02.11

Donizetti’s Lucia di Lammermoor, last seen downtown in 2002 and 1994 – starring Tiziana Fabbricini (opposite Marcello Giordani) and Laura Claycomb respectively, marked for Houston Grand Opera its second of two new productions to grace the Wortham this season. This also marked quite an important role debut, that of Russian soprano, former HGO studio artist and Tchaikovsky Competition winner Albina Shagimuratova, and also then the HGO debut of Greek-American tenor Dimitri Pittas (remembered from Met in HD as the tearfully plaintive Macduff in fine new production of Macbeth several seasons ago). Antonio Fogliani, with fine dvd (previously Emerging Pictures presentation) of Maria Stuarda from La Scala to his credit (starring Mariella Devia and Anna Caterina Antonacci), made his HGO debut conducting Lucia.

John Doyle, with more theater and Broadway than opera to his credit, for most pacing of this Lucia, laid out on a chilly abstract set, tended most of the way to tread lightly in depicting action on stage, motivations of characters involved, etc. The stage, apart from props of a couple of chairs, long table for the wedding scene, merely consisted of large wide panels or flats of murky, cloudy atmosphere – sitting at both straight and tilted, at times oddly tilted angles – as in part to symbolize a rigidly repressive quality to Scottish society – and the arbitrary murkiness of it all to come to grips, so to speak. What appeared to be nefarious contractual dealings would be seen ensuing mostly on narrow opening to stage rear over to stage left – more insightful than meddlesome. Very stiff, stylized procession of bridesmaids decked out in gray upstaged Raimondo both toward end of the ‘letter scene’ to start Act Two and midway through the tomb scene – as Scott Cantrell of Dallas Morning News found mildly risible. Also, characters interacting with each other tended at times to stand implausibly very close to each other, for situation at hand, relationships to portray. Such most often can not, on terms of emotional or physical intimacy, be plausibly assumed to be better than guarded.

The overall brooding quality of the sets and simplicity of design thereof most certainly did not rob the drama but little of its power or dynamic. Costuming, while mostly drab or abstract, abided well by historical accuracy standards; formal jig danced on stage early on in Act Three, Scene 2 (that before the Wolf’s Crag scene got restored had been Scene 1) was tasteful, but squeezed all a little tight by pressing accents from the orchestra pit, for it presumably not to linger a moment too long.

Still obviously new to singing the part, Albina Shagimuratova made a modest, humble waif type of creature out of Lucia. One writer has quipped already that she dramatically portrayed little of the mental instability of the character – that is, until her final scene on stage, the celebrated Mad Scene, for which the Doyle production suddenly became eccentrically elaborate, in comparison with earlier scenes. As Maria Callas knew full well, most of the insanity depicted in the part should come through the voice, inflection of the musical lines – as in context of when, in which aesthetic Donizetti wrote this opera, any excess of flailing about is bound to look very silly. Fortunately, Doyle and Shagimuratova readily stopped readily short of going over the top with any of the kind.

Shagimuratova had the requisite agility, evenness of line, sweet lyric timbre, mostly secure top to be reckoned quite an interpreter of Lucia – and certainly some real nuance, musical sensitivity for how Donizetti composed it as well. Moments of emotional immediacy with the text, especially at key moments during Act Two, were telling – all that could have been picked up from week of intensive coaching up in New York with Renata Scotto. And yet there here that seemed something altogether held back about her work dramatically - and in this particular instance placed under certain stylistic constraints to presumably fit in well with all else going on.

Legacy perhaps also of having worked with Scotto was a certain thickness that could occur around the break, making for especially during rushed ensembles toward end of Act Two a shrill, sharply tuned approach to acuti (high notes). A greater allowance for flexibility, including from the orchestra pit was necessary here toward ensuring Shagimuratova the best legato shaping of her lines, even individual profile thereof, but that for her opening aria in Act One and Part Two of the Mad Scene did not quite happen. She instead sounded constrained from filling out her lines with the requisite emotional weight and coloration (much leniency still available to do so without distorting proper shape to her lines, stylistic properties thereof).

Part One of the Mad Scene, in which Shagimuratova was eventually given all space she needed, freed her up to color numerous lines with half-lights, thereby to contrast much variety of shape and color very tellingly – all that worked a spell for as long as it would last over the entire hall. This was true, even with playful, even slightly witty distraction of making bridal train out of tablecloth previously covering length of very long rectangular table to represent nuptial festivities on stage, getting her hands smeared with blood, and then 9as thanks to Scott Hendricks for singing their duets together non legato with her?), smearing her stained hands on him. Fluently, most expressively sung cabaletta to her big scena in Act One was also enthralling. In scene with her brother near start of Act Two, one picked up a telling response to individual lines, only for cabaletta especially therein to have become too streamlined as well. With caution heeded as to how to better manage the break and making shifts, this could soon be an interpretation of Lucia to reckon – certainly not dependably surpassed thus far by either Netrebko or Dessay in still relatively new, cluttery Mary Zimmerman production at the Met.

Dimitri Pittas made a dashing figure of Edgardo, if not quite the harried, fraught profile or intensified as such vocally. The indeed fraught qualities of Edgardo’s plight were evident, but perhaps in manner hard to distinguish from that of anybody else much, glib this way, for both the natural lightness of timbre – and as especially toward end of Act Two, being rushed through rendered shapeless Act Two sextet and what follows. Expressive ardor for Lucia was genuine. With ‘assai’ part of Moderato assai’ well observed, but for genuine rubato, shaping thereof, the sempre legato missed, Pittas was equally at glib loss as much as Shagimuratova during a strictly weighted ‘Verranno a te’ moderate paced cabaletta ending Act One. One left for intermission without having picked up grasp of the rapt intensity written therein.

Worrisome about Pittas himself was some constriction right zeroed in around the break that for much of the evening he had trouble freeing himself – except with how he beautifully caressed his lines for ‘Fra poco a me ricovero’ near start of the Tomb Scene. Such relaxation allowed the listener to wrap oneself with ease into the noble profile of Edgardo’s lines and of emotional situation to the fore. Moderato marked cabaletta to this made case for pressing too much forward from the pit, thus for numerous constricted F-sharps from Pittas for not being allowed what is really indeed Edgardo’s space for shaping his lines. Whether the motivation was making 10:30 pm deadline or maintain things within chokehold of purist constraints or both should most likely remain a mystery. Suitable tone of defiance with swagger for lines to sing during the Wolf’s Crag scene Pittas made ring out well. Never was any sincerity in doubt, neither for the most part the musical sensitivity of this still young artist.

Scott Hendricks made moderately short (in stature), stocky appearance as the villainous Henry Ashton, good snarl and swagger of ‘Cruda, funesta smania’ and of some of Wolf’s Crag, but veered riskily close to coming up with stock villainy, mostly due to not being able to employ better than sketchy legato for his lines. Oren Gradus, of robust stature and voice, made a sonorous Raimondo - other than some of his extended range coming across mildly pitted or hollow, something he artfully attempted to hide with extra emphatic declamation during ‘Dalle stanze’, racconta to stunned wedding guests of what has transpired. The abstraction of this Lucia overall gave Gradus somewhat of a pass to settle for a stand up and sing rendition of the subtly duplicitous Raimondo, but he managed to make fine closing impression with his imprecation of Normanno for having been catalyst to tragedy unfolding – gravitas to horror expressed to Edgardo for his seemingly impulsive reaction to news of tragedy all about as well.

Nathaniel Peake looked dashing as Arturo Bucklaw, while hinting at wanting to shy away from F-sharps in his wedding arioso – without having to appear to be road kill for their being there – as has happened with stock casting of this thankless part at more famous houses than the Wortham. Beau Gibson was the astute, cleanly sung, purposeful Normanno, but with a few of his lines covered up by neighboring choristers, all handsomely profiled to near stage rear at opening of the first scene. Rachel Willis-Sorenson, newest among HGO studio members here made very handsome, supportive warm profile of Alisa and her lines. Choral preparation by Richard Bado left nothing to be desired.

Mention as aside to Fogliani here has stopped short of giving him the credit he deserves for his very smart shaping of the overall dramatic profile of Donzietti’s Lucia di Lammermoor. This was apparent right away with the confident giusto he employed with the opening, remarkably terse prelude to Act One that opens this, but also for stormy prelude to Wolf’s Crag as well. His ear for rich color and nuance to delineate form thereof is also fine, but likely expected from him of his forces here a little better weight from the lower strings of the Houston Grand Opera orchestra – remarkably lacking for ominously limning tremoli for to beckon by Enrico (into cabaletta to follow) for Lucia to join wedding festivities and to robustly accompany Edgardo crashing the party as well. Otherwise, this is the best the HGO orchestra has sounded here in perhaps several seasons.

Fogliani certainly could not be accused of any stodginess here, or of yielding to his singers’ thorough command of how all should be shaped to render his work that of a lifeless accompanist. However, what of the sublimely anguished turn in Lucia’s line during Mad scene cabaletta to minor subdominant on a high C-Flat that here got mercilessly shaved off to maintain consistently breezy pace through it?

In place of stodginess one had the sense of practically a definite compartmentalization of, detachment in negotiating musical proceedings, even remindful somewhat of a young Riccardo Muti – more so except perhaps for two moments than of Patrick Summers and his ‘period’ motivated approach to bel canto thus far. It is perhaps not to scrupulize, not to blow off the dust of tradition enough to mark with light (unmarked poco allargando) lift the crest of opening line to ‘Per te d’immenso giubilo’, but the swagger to inform animated triplets (to prevent them from turning stiff) to spin off from such then goes missing - and somewhat did so here – making for detached instead of sustained framing this choral interlude should provide.

The score here was presented unabridged, except just in part in interest of keeping the action moving, for cutting several repeats. The obvious fire in Fogliani’s approach, especially when not excessively sweeping other elements out of the way, made for a refreshing debut here – even though one might reckon a better filled out, more holistic approach to presenting all of Donzett’s Lucia di Lammermoor in new production such as just opened here.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , ,

Wednesday, April 21, 2010

HGO: Tchaikovsky Queen of Spades - Vladimir Galuzin (Hermann) - features very strong cast and chorus, but other facets weaker - 18.04.10

It is nearly thirty years now since Houston Grand Opera last put on Tchaikovsky’s Pique-Dame, in more traditional setting than now – our first Pique-Dame at the Wortham Center. HGO has brought in numerous good ingredients for success here, in terms of casting Vladimir Galuzin and Judith Forst (Countess), plus for leading parts, three very gifted young singers in their HGO debuts.

In spite of compromises, it is still thrilling to see Galuzin here as Hermann. He was the best Hermann around ten years ago – even with Gregorian, Domingo, and Heppner still around. Early on this past decade, Galuzin bought into temptation of pushing the chest voice through the passaggio that had me fear he would not keep most pitches above it much longer. Final line of the storm scene included the high B, very sinewy, but with still plenty of ring. It was enough alone to bring down the house. A few less challenging high notes later on however got stuck, not quite firmly landing on pitch. His leathery negotiation of the break continues to be worrisome. Hermann for Galuzin clearly is a very driven man - not as something to deliver on the surface, extroverty, but instead deeply from within. There were numerous times throughout suggestions here of the subtlety with which before Galuzin had come to grasp the psychological complexity of Hermann musically so very well.

Galuzin still proved yesterday able to sing softly, albeit less flexibly so than nine years ago, plus less often than he should. Natural darkening of his sound, with age, is expected. Bronze already in the tone before was certainly remindful of Vladimir Atlantov, but there was then better focus to the sound - leaner, more subtly flexible to respond to musical demands. Galuzin then too had a way of taking the introversion of singing Hermann even a step further then than I ever heard from the still estimably fine Atlantov. Dramatically, the well varied neurosis of Hermann, impassioned reach for Lisa, is still gripping today. The look in his eyes during confrontation with the Countess was most fearful - that is, with our inability to see well her face.

Tatiana Monogarova joined Galusin as a fetching, somewhat naïve Lisa. The utter girlishness of Lisa started to characterize Hermann - Galusin chasing her in and out amongst numerous choristers - as something suggesting a pederast. Whether or not on purpose, it put Hermann at risk of being two-dimensional villain instead of the complex anti-hero he really is . Tone quality started off cloudy for Monogarova in opening duet with Pauline; other than strain for several notes up high, everything opened out freely.

Monogarova’s lustrous tone abetted natural curvature of Lisa’s wide-ranging ador very capably and alluringy – even with still slight compromise to legato and slight occlusion around the break. She then came across only slightly heavy for Chloe during the pastourelle. She opted to play Lisa as having difficulty understanding Hermann and as lying tragically outside of abiity to grasp of real situation at hand. Such made for a very involving Lisa in every way.

Galina Gorchakova, less detailed an actress than Monogarova, had a more mature take on Lisa when paired with Galusin in St Petersburg years ago, portraying her as intuitively understanding situation vey well while very affectingly reaching out to Hermann in vain. Monogarova brings to Lisa and Tatiana as well acutely precise nuance in countenance and gesture that is also very compelling.

Icelandic baritone Tomas Tomasson was Tomsky, looking young as the rough-hewn soldier, though a little demurely on purpose toward maintaining good camaraderie with his buddies. A little introversion in acting Tomsky seemed slightly awkward from early on – something unfortunately to explain well later. An oaken, ruddy color to the sound fit close to perfect, with top to freely open out, conspicuously so for the ‘tri karty’ aria in Act One; a little hollowing out from lower end of midrange on down is worrisome though. Lustiness with Tomsky’s witty couplets in the final scene got compromised by excessively annoying nonsensical stage business Tomasson would have done better without.

Vassily Ladyuk was the charming Yeletsky, at least until making lout out of the prince during the final gambling scene, both contrary to the quality of Ladyuk’s voice - with stiff pointing of any irony in playing Yeletsky so unattractively. Before then, most everything went very well for him, with only minor compromise of legato while reaching low rduring his eloquently phrased Second Act romanza. Ladyuk has a very lyric voice, suitable for Mozart and other mostly lyric repertoire, and hopefully much lieder as well in the near future. Maria Markina was the equally lyric Pauline, and very sympathetically sang both her dolorous song in Act One and pastourelle mozartiana.

All HGO studio rank supporting cast members performed very capably, showing what considerable depth HGO still maintains this way. If there was any stand-out, it was Catherine Martin, after having made heavy going of Gianetta in Elixir recently. As Governess, she made scolding of the girls at Lisa's social gathering humorous and warmly inflected - holding everyone’s attention very well, except for all of Lisa’s friends on stage, all looking as though having heard her talk on what is ladylike and what is not too often before. Choral preparation by Richard Bado continued most resolute and dependable with highly supportive childrens’ chorus - notably incisive the boy captain of Phillip Bevers.

Though affected in how she trotted across stage more often than necessary, Judith Forst proved utter paragon of simplicity as the Countess. As successful as much other casting was, this was the one true thoroughly unqualified success for this. The weariness, crankiness, mysterious authority of her lines, infusion of nostalgia through the Gretry aria with which she informed the part put her in great company as close to definitive, barring having Regine Crespin show up instead. Oddly enough, due to a combination of reasons, we unfortunately had at the Wortham an audience impatient with so much music at quiet volume for twenty minutes - for one of the best two scenes in this, Tchaikovsky himself knew. One here had to listen attentively past much coughing, shuffling in one’s seats to be able to hear this scene at all. The Muscovite Venus’s vulnerability in having to face Hermann, half-naked, from a bathtub made for exciting theater - with Forst’s back to us. Here it was hard to argue that the Jones production lacked anything, even with soon before Forst’s feet dangling over foot of her bed while stiff sideways to sing the Gretry aria.

Richard Jones, represented from Welsh National Opera by Roy Rallo here, with Carlo Rizzi at musical helm, however seemed on the same page as Rizzi in one near-fatal way. That is contentment to streamline so much of what got invested in this, and leave it to intermittent insights what Pique-Dame is really about. Except in the most generic sense, there was little in the way of connectivity, except to depend on several fine singing actors to provide it. Good or consistently better than threadbare interest in maintaining strong narrative sense to Pique Dame was lacking. Much built-in contrast between scenes, sound worlds between the dark and sinister and for the intervening rococo pastiche got minimized, for cause of vague intellectualizing.

Carlo Rizzi showed propensity for keeping textures relatively clear, a sensibly forward moving pace through this, a good ache for the grand line on climactic pages, and for final scene, at the casino, ebullient incisiveness against much hard, amplified slamming against gaming table and floor during this scene. A little thinness in quality of the HGO orchestra worked against Rizzi undercutting the score’s dark colors numerous times; so did at times some amplification of voices, creating imbalance with the orchestra, especially at points where screen came down to end several scenes, cutting off most of the stage, to facilitate efficient scene changes. Rizzi was then partly responsible for what resulted in shallow aural perspective quite often.

Up until obvious storm, contrast between differing moods, activity of the summer garden scene got streamlined. A little greater intensity of focus where it should count for something did not quite emerge. The sense should be of Hermann’s perception of all going on about him - of as much we perceive Hermann can at least halfway grasp. The Dostoevskian character of this scene is a obvious to the best interpreters of Pique-Dame, but became thrown off here. Accents for grandiose opening of Act Two came across flaccid. Hint of expressionism in Tchaikovsky’s scoring of first three out of last four scenes got minimized, especially early on during Act Three.

‘Safety first’ in both keeping things constantly moving and ensemble together became password for the barracks scene. Rizzi also denied Monogarova sufficient shape to several particularly expressive lines as Lisa anticipates Hermann’s arrival alongside winter canal. The demonic, obsessive character of Hermann’s drive to get back to the gaming room got undercut by Rizzi’s streamlining of a repeated, insistent descending, rocking figure among lower winds. Not on Rizzi’s part alone, Pique-Dame seemed to stretch out longer than it actually did. It was in understating excessively sharp contrasts in character that this music could be left to meander and then occasionally lose clear sense of direction entirely.

The Richard Jones production features an abstract, expressionist set with stage rear adorned by panels to match. Boudoirs for Lisa and the Countess make it seem that aristocracy has seen better days - perhaps more likely to reflect the Soviet era, replacing different shades of dark gray with a drab green and white. Bed of Hermann and gaming table in Act Three were both steeply raked – with casino in abstract disarray. A panel through ceiling into box for all these scenes served as most likely a skylight, out of which can appear enough of Hermann first of all, then ominously the skeleton of the Countess later – latter symbolizing closing vise of death upon Hermann. Chorus appeared in good mostly black office attire, tending to move in row formation across the stage - most stilted in oval shaped scurrying reception lines for two festive choral passages in Act Two.

Mimetic hand motions, remindful of chorus in Pier’Alli's production of I Puritani at cinemas last fall, were common; especially tiresome was frequent entering and exiting of chorus on and off stage, as to blur line between reality and Hermann’s imagination. This became most distracting – chorus literally quickly jogging past – while Hermann enters embankment scene in Act Three. Individual characters would occasionally be doubled by an extra main character - often rival for attention or affections - walking in precise parallel step behind. Chorus was most effective cowering all about during approach of storm halfway through Act One. Lighting tended to be stark – especially on a silhouetted Hermann to open Act Two and on puppet show for the pastourelle, inoffensively but inertly commenting upon Hermann’s gambling fixation.
Some of all this was interesting, but mostly just to reveal a stylized manner with Queen of Spades. Seeing Lisa as constantly girlishly running, scurrying about, cowering backwards turned silly and banal. Monogarova had plenty of nuance on her own to contribute - and may have rescued her character alone. Skeleton of the Countess looked between redolent of Felix Murnau and of Graham Vick's production of Pique-Dame – perhaps as homage or tribute to what is also a mediocre production of this.

Where the staging really became a cop-out, following odd staging of Lisa’s suicide at ending (non-)embankment scene was the final scene. Tomsky and “his (new) rentboy” engaged for several minutes in messing around; competing then with Tomsky’s couplets was gyrating dance by ‘rent-boy’ accompanying following gambling chorus and to one-up Tomsky, so to speak. Tomsky on the prowl about Hermann’s body, sprawled out against the gambling table provided finishing touch upon new low for malodorous banality five minutes earlier - all lacking sufficient irony and/or suggestive power to have managed to say anything.

Such happening, that this is still Bible Belt to some extent, can so easily provide folks here proof text toward discouraging challenging productions here. We in fact, instead of getting what out there might be truly innovative or insightful, risk stuff that in a chic way cheaply poses as being modern, such as the Annabel Arden Elixir last fall here. This production, even with what intermittent flashes of insight it gave us, helped make Tchaikovsky’s narrative aimlessly meander. One expected more humor, irony in approaching Pique-Dame. Other than for schoolboy-ish Hermann scrambling across card table for the Countess (wearing floozey blonde wig) dealing out cards – humorous indeed – it never became forthcoming.

This Pique-Dame, regardless its accolades from the British press, made for an overall dull afternoon, especially in considering what price tag must accompany the name of Richard Jones. He is credited many years back with a deemed important but overrated Ring at Convent Garden conducted (and despised) by Bernard Haitink, English National Opera Lulu, Shakespearean Verdi at Glyndebourne conducted by Vladimir Jurowski and Munich Lohengrin.

Good for HGO to have picked up instead a Lev Dodin production of this from Paris (now out on dvd) - so darn cute, adorable a Chloe Galuzin is for the pastourelle you want to immediately take him home alone with you to have date any still unattached (or detached) daughter, sister, or niece of yours. The intermezzo (pastourelle) looks better than even what rustics in Midsummer Night’s Dream could have concocted. There is a such a fertile imagination at work here, with Galuzin an alternatively, foppishly cartoon-ish and neurotic Hermann - infused with accents he likely picked up from definitively playing Grishka in Rimsky Korsakov’s City of Kitezh back in the 1990’s. Vera Firsova, a great Ludmilla in Glinka’s opera fifty-plus years back – able to sing rings around Anna Netrebko - would have definitely very willingly stepped aside for Galuzin, could he have been Chloe back then. Such comparison had hardly ever occurred to me before.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , ,

Thursday, February 4, 2010

HGO: A mostly unerring Turn of the Screw eerily haunts the Wortham - Amanda Roocroft (HGO debut), Andrew Kennedy - Neil Armfield production

Benjamin Britten’s Midsummer Night’s Dream, to paraphrase Neil Armfield, represents (stasis of) being in a most utopian sense caught in a state of childhood (purity and) innocence. Armfield very successfully produced Midsummer Night's Dream here a year ago. Both enclosed within, handed out openly is ideal of being free of the corruption by adult world all about – Dream construed as oasis or Eden amidst a very dry or arid land.

After catharsis like Turn of the Screw, it should be. Houston Grand Opera scheduled the appearance of these two pieces, a year apart, in flip order, leaving so to speak (paraphrasing Peter Quint) 'ceremony of innocence all drowned' at last. Midsummer Night’s Dream exquisitely blossoms out within the oeuvre of Benjamin Britten, and vice versa, became the flip side of this setting of Henry James. The simplicity with which Neil Armfield approaches the operas of Britten remains paramount here. Such remains a virtue for what is the shortest of three taken on so far here but also the most complex of them in numerous ways. In it is quite a challenge, and if not met here in all aesthetic ways possible, still a very strong attempt at it. Numerous elements to this Turn of the Screw made it very well worth going to see it.

HGO music director Patrick Summers was at the helm. With orchestra involving fourteen musicians, he at times could be found only as strong as his weakest link. Weak links - every participant in this a soloist - out of HGO orchestra ranks, were not too numerous - just sufficient to be distracting. Even though the magic of Screw is of a very dark and sinister quality, none of this element should be rendered neutral at all, there also being those episodes composed to sound innocuous instead.

As cited in Phyllis Howard’s commentary on Turn of the Screw (Cambridge), the work came under a little drubbing by the composer Malipiero for leaving all the scoring for this opera precariously exposed. Strongest in this ensemble were the playing of Elisabeth Priestley (oboe), Dennis Whitaker (double-bass), Barrett Sills (cello), Sarah Cranston (horn) and also Bethany Self (keyboards). Weakest were first, second violins, including HGO concertmaster Denise Tarrant, flute, and percussion (two players).

Gian Francesco Malipiero mentioned acute need for each part to havee to register at or near height of its expressive potential for (the) chamber music scoring to work; he construed this unable to match realistic expectations. Such became true when command of one’s instrument with Britten’s purposefully awkward writing became tentative.

Even though Britten uses tone rows, here the central row based on ascending perfect fourths in whole tone spelling for his theme and variations structure, his adaptation of such is not serial. This is so, even while manipulating tone centers half-tones apart. Even so, his development of his material is interwoven, complex laced with much symbolism. There is even some of what is called a hard kernel to some of the musical symbolism that must be heard, even if subconsciously, for this music to fire off on all cylinders. Enough of what element was here to make the HGO Turn of the Screw effective; still more on part of Summers and his players one would hope could have been possible. Acute ear for balances and interaction between varied activities going on was lacking, especially with gaps in playing quality from a handful of soloists therein.

Patrick Summers, when not hamstrung by limitations listed above, has come a good part of the way in coming to grips with Britten’s complex vision here. He made mostly good choice of tempos, moving the action forward well, and drew out of Britten’s music many of its numerous colors and implications. However, there were a number of moments that sounded pushed – some of for instance Peter Quint’s melismatic sextuplet lines, when doubled by orchestral players – played in rhythmic space at times for what might fit five sextuplets instead of six – during finale to Act One but not there alone. Due in part to dull flute playing, contrast in color between opposing sonorities of a pristine nocturnal D Major and encroaching sinister A-Flat tritone below (or from below) was compromised in scene (‘The Tower’) during which Peter Quint is first sighted. Duet for horn and celesta was introspectively very effective for one of the opera's more expansive interludes (called variations). Extended mostly unaccompanied solo for oboe (Priestley) with sinister insinuations from double-bass also fully made its impact.

Some high raising of arms in the air in what Summers turned into a somewhat scherzo-esque close to the scene immediately preceding variation and closing scene - passacaglia for final scene closing out the theme and variations design to the whole opera - exacerbated instead of effectively raising dramatic tension to anticipate the finale. All fortunately did cumulatively come together as building toward what resulted in the harrowing final moments of this opera. That Summers indeed has at least some ear for what goes on here became evident during the playing of very icy sonorities from string harmonics toward end of Act One and incisive staccato for ‘atonal’ leaning fugato interlude midway through Act Two.

Neil Armfield was most deft at finding just the proper amount of space between rear mirror laden casements for ghosts to appear and then often descend out of view, often walking backwards. Not just as path of least resistance, Armfield deftly chose to leave it up to the viewer how to halfway correctly interpret what is going on. With such there was certailnly neither ambiguity betrayed nor explanation added, solution found that perhaps not even Britten or his librettist may have intended for us to have. Costuming was period, most effective with the billowing dress in which one found Miss Jessel and that for boy Miles - with how light from rear would hit him as covered in long white nightshirt and also in making procession in front of mirrors costumed in purple robe with Flora in white.

Moving of casements around on stage between scenes - even as tightly encroaching on quartet of singing actors at one point - was unerringly effective. Some subtle emphasis could perhaps have been found however, for early scenes of nursery rhymes for Miles and Flora, with for comic relief just the playfulness of these scenes emphasized, that music here was left alone to provide. It is perhaps churlish to mention since better perhaps to do nothing instead of too much some other ways in handling such passages.

A long crumpled sheet of iridescent fabric supplied river or symbolism thereof for the set in an uncannily effective way. Especially the dramatic rolling back of it at end of scene where Flora, while being taken away by Mrs Grose, claims to be able to see nothing of any ghosts haunting the Governess was quite a coup de theatre. A flaring purplish red with which it showed up once or twice, as opposed to a dull gray as it first appeared made for great contrast in both what one would expect and to dark coloration all about. Contrast between sets for the first two scenes of Act Two was also very effective. For colloquy between the two ghosts - the tall mirror casements are quite oppressively to front of the stage, light smoke billowing forth from behind. ‘The Bells’ featured ample semblance of normalcy with fine wide-angle view of most of the stage and clear lighting.

In terms of interaction between characters, most of this was also effective – with what challenge it might pose to make the children appear possessed. Both Andrew Kennedy (Peter Quint) and Tamara Wilson (Miss Jessel) looked malevolent – with it being left subjective how much of such malevolence, if any at all, should be perceived by anybody else, either on or off stage – Neil Armfield’s way of showing complete respect.

Amanda Roocroft made probably the most important HGO debut for 2009-2010 here thus far as the Governess. Her command of musical idiom was absolutely complete. Her revealed a woman certainly rattled, slightly unnerved by presence of evil at Bly (country house at which most of this takes place), but a bit blandly to make some of the neurosis of the Governess subdued; this may have been on purpose. With warm tone, she encompassed the vocal range of this part with ease, Roocroft made count the doting, overweening characteristics of the Governess toward Miles especially. During ‘The Tower”, so evocative of night, she floated what are on the surface her calm lines over crest of high B-Flat with fine ease, while expressively giving hint of inner agitation - obvious why moments later with first sighting of Peter Quint.

Accompaniment for the Governess’s musings (just past start of Act 2), “Lost in my labyrinth,” sounded a little more like a scramble from especially upper strings than it should. Roocroft made quasi-heroic, with clearly suggesting absence of stable basis for it, the Governess's confidence in rescuing Miles. She then moments later made so distraught her quoting his mysterious song, ‘Malo’, right before last curtain fell.

Judith Forst was the dramatically involved Mrs Grose, as character ineffective, passive toward hope of curbing the Governess’s neuroses, but singing a part lying slightly high for her at this stage of her career. Her “Dear God, is there no end,” refrain starting and re-starting arioso during fifth scene (“The Window”), carried sufficient force, but with percussion underneath (so often unvaried in dynamics) too much louder than doubling violins of her lines for good support to them here.

The last role for HGO studio alumna Tamara Wilson at the Wortham was Amelia in Verdi’s Bsllo in maschera; it obviously stressed her beyond vocal capacity to sustain it. For Roocroft being also lyric - the Ballo Amelia not quite being suitable for her either - Roocroft projected more loudly than Wilson singing together with her - Wilson the brighter on top. The intelligence of Wilson in having avoided doing much damage by engaging in such previous misadventure became obvious in her fine limning of Miss Jessel here. Standing next to Andrew Kennedy, a definitive Peter Quint, Wilson was undaunted here in having to cover a wide range - with need to project well throughout. She elicited too a decent ear for the odd intervals and spacing in her part while making the menace of her text so elaborately set to music count also. With Kennedy having to opt for something more subtle, Wilson’s Miss Jessel was the more obviously menacing figure on stage for this. Wilson’s tone for low notes had the right covered, dark quality in contrast with much brighter sound on top. With decent legato at last she capitalized fully on making all her lines count here, each of them with what punch she could give them.

Matching Wilson vigorously was Joelle Harvey as Flora. Harvey conveyed the manner of a young girl with her petite appearance on stage, but vocally revealed some real carrying power that at times betrayed vocal maturity to extent one practically had to suspend disbelief. Her gangly acting and countenance went much distance in making up for such lapse – conveying some hope too of Flora being able to stand up to situation all about.

By way of contrast was the obviously more passive Miles of Michael Kepler Meo. One saw through Meo definitely the more brooding, introverted child from among the two - and appearing the more possessed throughout. In spectral manner, tone was often covered to the point of being slightly too reserved. A few notes failed to quite adequately speak beyond the footlights. He had to have on purpose projected a somewhat resinous, hollow tone, almost as to resemble wooden (alto) flute in low register; his doing so conveyed much mystery. With Miles eventually put on the defensive, he made his lines take on all clarity and incisive attack necessary.

Guiding many of his steps through this was the chilling Peter Quint of Andrew Kennedy, much of which played as simply though deceptively innocuous at least up until near - at least while in company of others - point he goads Miles to steal the letter. From starting as Prologue, Kennedy’s clarity of line and with text, making all speak most effectively, was absolutely first-rate. He sounds like a high baritone at times, but with free extension up fairly high – never going excessively so here – projecting with fine ease and subtle variety some very artful writing in so many melismas, chains of sextuplets. He disallowed being rushed too much through this, as to otherwise deny himself full shape to such passages. He was heard acoustically placed on stage and off in subtle variety of ways engaging such – considering the varied multicultural allotment of sources upon which Britten drew for writing Peter Quint. His timbre and artistry would suit his ideally being cast here as Pelleas for Debussy HGO has never yet staged before. We would do well to attempt bringing Kennedy here for a full evening of recital as well.

With several changes to orchestral personnel and a little more rehearsal, familiarity with this work, it would be interesting to hear what better stab Summers might make at Turn of the Screw, toward making it a more complete experience. One would ideally seek something still more specifically eerie out of this than felt already at Wortham Center this week – so much that Britten acutely points out in his scoring in manifold subtle ways.

Guiding hands and voices of especially the malevolent Peter Quint (Andrew Kennedy) and of the Governess (Amanda Roocroft), in addition to the fine staging excellently compensated toward leading this where it should go. I surmise too their influence abetted Tamara Wilson toward making Miss Jessel so sinister as she accomplished here. It was such, should be that Turn of the Screw, Neil Armfield and his cast of his players all leave us, via intended psychological murk throughout, asking more questions than finding answers.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , ,

free counters